Speaking of John Calhoun, he chimed in on a Hacker News thread last month regarding his experience working with Steve Lemay at Apple:
I think Steve Lemay is a good guy. I kind of fought with him when
I was an engineer, he was a young, new designer (at Apple). But I
always respected his point of view — even when we argued.
When Jobs came back to Apple in the latter 1990’s “Design” slowly
came to have an outsized role. I was one half of the engineering
team that owned Preview (the application) when Steve Lemay became
a seemingly regular presence in the hallway. As the new “Aqua” UI
elements arrived in the OS like the “drawer” and toolbar, Steve
and his boss (forgetting his name right now — Greg Somebody?)
were often making calls about our UI implementation.
I guarantee that was Greg Christie, who is in my opinion the least-known-but-most-missed person at Apple.
Steve Lemay insisted the drawer live on the right side of the
window. This was inexplicable to me. I saw the layout of Preview
as hierarchical: the left side of the content driving the right
side. You click a thumbnail on the left (in the drawer) the window
content on the right changes to reflect the thumbnail clicked on.
Steve said, no, drawer on the right.
“Why? Why the hell would we do that?”
Steve was quick: “The Preview app is about the content. The
content is king.”
I admit that I still disagreed with him after the exchange, but I
had a new respect for him as a designer because he was able to
articulate a rationale for his decision. I suppose I was
prejudiced to expect hand-waving from designers.
It’s a good sign when you lose an argument but gain respect for those arguing the opposing side. (And, Calhoun notes, the Preview sidebar eventually did move to the left, after split views replaced drawers in AppKit.)
(Addendum: Steve also invented the early Safari URL text field
that also doubled as a progress bar. Instant hate from me when I
saw it: it was as if the text of the URL you entered was being
selected as the page loaded. So I’m old-school and Steve had
some new ideas…)
I had the same reaction as Calhoun when I first wrote about Safari, two days after it was announced and released as a public beta at Macworld Expo in January 2003. (That was a year before I created Markdown, so I had to edit raw HTML just now to update a few broken links to working versions at the Internet Archive.) I wrote then:
Progress Bar Behind Location Field
Hideous. It looks like partially-selected text. Please scrap it.
But by 2009, reviewing the public beta of Safari 4, I had changed my mind, and admitted I was wrong in my initial assessment of the progress-bar-in-location-field combo control:
But I quickly grew accustomed to it, and soon grew to miss it when
using other browsers. It was, I soon decided, a damn clever way to
show progress in a way that was prominent while the page was
actually loading, and without taking up any additional space on
the screen after loading was complete.
That innovation is a nice feather in Lemay’s cap.